Evan Martin (evan) wrote in evan_tech,
Evan Martin

user scripts and software development

Someone sent me an update for one of my greasemonkey userscripts, and mentioned the comments on userscripts.org, so I poked around there. One of the more prominent tags (making it to the front page, at least) is for LiveJournal and LJ, ranging from fixing bugs (wrong form character limits on update pages) to adding features (expanding the comment threading inline, forcing your style on all viewed pages, allowing commenting on friends pages without loading a new page).

Iit's always a bit strange to see how many people hack features in GM scripts. We've observed this at work, too: Mihai hacks gmail features rather than implementing them directly for two major reasons:
  1. It's much easier to write a bit of Javascript than it is to check out, learn the code base, and especially get a whole {gmail,lj,etc.} install going. Even back when I was comfortable with the first two of those steps for LiveJournal development, the last one was enough of a hurdle to discourage me from writing features.
  2. Even after you've implemented a feature, many of them are policy decisions -- like the userscript to make all profile links on LJ be "full" links -- and they're unlikely to be incorporated upstream anyway.
I think #2 mostly applies to server-side apps, especially if it's not hard to repeatedly merge your changes into your local branch of an upstream client app. But #1 is a real barrier to attracting developers and contributors, and I'm sure using funky version control systems doesn't help.

  • regular-expression parsing

    "Now you have two problems." Wikipedia has preliminary support for some new expressions in their markup, including an "if" statement. From the…

  • wikimedia drive

    The wikimedia foundation has a 2005 budget summary up. They want, among other things, $125k for hardware for this quarter alone. (The earlier…

  • two more wikipedia remarks

    I was thinking about some toy projects for Wikipedia data again and I poked around some Wikipedia code. Two observations: Good'ol timwi strikes…

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic
    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.